Fatcow Icon
Easley High band director position sparks controversy
by Sandy Foster
Sep 30, 2009 | 6989 views | 14 14 comments | 16 16 recommendations | email to a friend | print
The Easley High School Green Wave Marching Band was in full uniforms performing during halftime of the Easley-Wren football game. Supporters say the band should be in contention for the state title this year. Easley’s first competition will be Saturday at Pendleton.
The Easley High School Green Wave Marching Band was in full uniforms performing during halftime of the Easley-Wren football game. Supporters say the band should be in contention for the state title this year. Easley’s first competition will be Saturday at Pendleton.
slideshow
EASLEY — Two years ago, the band director at Easley High School left to serve in the military, and now he’s ready to return.

Dr. Henry Hunt confirmed that Charles Hamlett will return for the 2010-2011 school year. But some parents and students are happy with the job current director Patrick Mainieri is doing and want him to stay in the position.

Several spoke out at Monday night’s school board meeting, telling the board what a good job Mainieri has done since he took charge of the band.

Will Hillegeist, who graduated from EHS in 2009, said the band program had grown under Manary’s direction, and he asked that the board keep the students’ best interest in mind by keeping him on as band director.

“Don’t ignore the strides made in the past two years,” he said.

Hillegeist’s mother Pam Hillegeist also spoke on Mainieri’s behalf.

“I’m not here to badmouth anybody on staff, but the students need stability,” she said.

Student Abbey Thompson spoke of Mainieri’s character and his dedication to his students and the band program.

“You say you want to do what’s best for the students, but I find that hard to believe if you’re willing to disrupt or throw away what Patrick Mainieri has built over the past few years,” she said.

But board chairman Jim Shelton pointed out that in bringing Hamlett back to the position, the school district is following laws regarding military service of state employees.

Shelton said the board had to make a tough decision and that Mainieri’s efforts were not ignored.

Board member Alex Saitta, who represents the Pickens area, also said the board did not ignore the parents’ and students’ concerns when making the decision to bring Hamlet back as director next year.

But he said that according to federal law, when an employee goes away to serve in the military, they must be re-employed in “the escalator position or a position of like seniority, status and pay.”

Saitta said bringing Hamlett back as director of another school in the district would have been considered a drop in status, so the board had no choice.

“The law was pretty clear to us,” he said. “We’re very sympathetic to all you had to say, and there was a lot of relevance to what you had to say, but according to the law, it is irrelevant.”

Comments
(14)
Comments-icon Post a Comment
Lemondrop
|
October 06, 2009
It's more than slightly humorous to read some of the comments here......

First off, anyone who either volunteers for military service and is sent off to basic training and then advanced training OR someone who is in the reserves/National Guard and is called up is not able to 'double dip'. The actual situation differs depending on if the member of the military is employed in the private or public sector.

As a state employee, a public school teacher falls under 'South Carolina Code of Laws' Section 8-7-90 (available at http://www.jobs.sc.gov/OHR/employee/military_leave_provisions.pdf).

You can go and read that for yourself.

If this sort of allegation is any example of the type of ill-informed jabs being thrown around in a situation that has, by all appearances, become so full of drama and histrionics so as to be funny if it weren't so pitiful, then it's no wonder there's so much confusion.

Never forget that this is, in the end, a question dealing with a high school band program. In an era where thousands of people are living, fighting, and dying in harsh conditions so that you can have the protected privilege of 'competing' for a plastic trophy on Saturdays, there are certainly better ways to spend your time and efforts....and if this is any indication of how Easley supports the valiant men and women who 'dare' to offer such protective services, then I'm embarrassed I can even find it on a map, more or less having once called it home.
gamecocks1229
|
October 06, 2009
First of all, no one was told not to send "Happy Grams", they were told to be repsectful and say positive things, no negative things. I know this to be a fact because I was there when Manieri ask this of the students and parents at Pendleton last week. The only thing that really is of concern at this point is to be positive and show the kids respect and support for the next several weeks with all the competitions ahead of them. They do NOT need to hear parents/people bickering over what is going to take place a year from now. This matter will take care of itself if everyone will just sit back and let the chips fall where they may....everthing happens for a reason. I don't know Mr. Hamlett and this is my first year having any affiliation with Mr. Manieri and I have no problems with him. I have watched and he is very good with the kids and he gets just as excited when they are successful as they do. I just fill like at this time everyone just needs to be positive and supportive for the kids sake and see what happens!
monja1
|
October 06, 2009
First of all, Mr. Hamlett had respect for the students, he knew their names and their parents names. You mentioned Mr. Mainieri helping students financially for trips, this is also true of Mr. Hamlett you may just not have known because he may not have made it public that the student needed funds. Another thing is you say that we shouldn't put it on Mr. Mainieri shoulders, but you are all putting things on Mr. Hamlett's shoulders. How is that fair? Also, i am happy that the students did get grand champs at pendleton, but if you look back on previous years we also recieved grand champs and other awards like they did under Mr. Hamlett. You should go to bandlink.org and look at the results and scores from previous years. While i was in band i was happy, having fun, and working hard just like the children are today. Another thing there are not just a few people who are not against Mr. Hamlett coming back they just don't feel the need to speak out because there is nothing that any of us can do about this whole situation because it is a LEGAL matter and he is getting his job back whether we want him to or not. As for RESPECT.. i find it very DISRESPECTFUL to hear that people from Easley are no longer allowed to send out "happy grams" due to a comment made from someone at Pendleton. That shows no respect or leadership at all. Also that is showing a bad example for the students. I know that a lot of people do not want Mr. Hamlett back at Easley and that is fine if that is your opinion, however, he has built the program and will continue to do so when he returns.

and not trying to be rude but before calling two people out for what they've said you may want to make sure that you are talking about the right person. Ehsalumni is not the daughter of ehsparent.
EHSBandMom
|
October 05, 2009
As another note... I would like to add for "ehsalumni" and her mother "ehsparent", what you may have experienced with Mr. Maineri can not be all on his shoulders... as we all know it takes two. He has to look out for the entire band. I understand that your family may have been friends with the Hamletts and I am sorry this doesn't suit your liking... I also know that because of the "beef" you have with Mr. Maineri... your are overlooking the good he is doing. As for money... he even made sure kids who wouldn't have been able to go on band trips, etc. got to go because he had parents he could go to that would lend that extra financial support for them... I even paid for an entire trip for a child because her family was being hit by one set back after another.... you may be familiar with that child. Mr. Maineri is the one to be thanked for that help! He expressed a need and explained to me what I could do to help... HE TAKES CARE OF THESE KIDS! He has made NO statements about this situation to students or parents. He is very humble and thankful to be a part of this program. I AM CURRENTLY THERE WITH A CHILD STILL IN THE PROGRAM while this situation is going on and he has given the utmost respect for Mr. Hamlett. He is an upstanding guy who has not bad mouthed Mr. Hamlett.... and I am actually around to hear it if he did!
EHSBandMom
|
October 05, 2009
"...that's really showing good leadership. I feel this should have been an easy transaction in no way was Mainieri going to loose his job but, the power went straight to his head and in no way is he ready to be knocked off his high horse yet."

Your statements do not express very good leadership skills or RESPECT. You are failing to take into consideration the feelings of the students this currently effects. I am sorry you are one of very FEW who may have a problem with Mr. Maineri. Mr. Maineri has always shown me the greatest respect. Unlike Mr. Hamlett, he knows the names of ALL his students and their parents. This to me in it's self shows his respect for the studnets and their parents. I witnessed what happened at the game and what you stated isn't exactly the way it happened. Luckily the child turned out to be fine. Hopefully you were at Saturday's Competition to see the Maineri lead band accomplish a 1st place 4A victory and win overall Grand Champions...no matter how you look at it or who's side you are on ...Easley Band is winning! That is the result of hard work and dedication by the students an Maineri. Right now the students are happy, working hard, and accomplishing thier goals... I say if it isn't broken... don't fix it. Would Easley remove a Football Coach who was winning every game? I doubt it.
ehsalumni
|
October 01, 2009
I completely agree with the previous 3 statements. This whole situation is out of control. I am an alumnus of Easley and participated in band for all 4 years. As a former student I understand the concern of the parents and students. That of consistency. BUT just like ehsconcernedparent said. When have we ever been able to choose our teachers before? Every year the students get a new teacher for every subject and somehow they manage. Part of life is learning how to adjust to change.

During the time I was at Easley I had 3 band directors. It was very sad when the first one left. It was hard and took a long time to adjust. But no one ever thought that this individual had “abandoned the students” or that he “didn’t care about our band program.” We all knew that change is a part of life. It happens and then you move on. Believe it or not, there IS more to life than band. I learned this very less from Mr. Hamlett.

Yes, band is supposed to be fun. But it’s more than that, you learn life lessons. Mr. Hamlett taught me things through band that I use every single day. Those lessons of hard work, determination, and the most important (and from observation, the one that seems to be completely non-existent now) RESPECT.

ehsalumni
|
October 01, 2009
I completely agree with the previous 3 statements. This whole situation is out of control. I am an alumnus of Easley and participated in band for all 4 years. As a former student I understand the concern of the parents and students. That of consistency. BUT just like ehsconcernedparent said. When have we ever been able to choose our teachers before? Every year the students get a new teacher for every subject and somehow they manage. Part of life is learning how to adjust to change.

During the time I was at Easley I had 3 band directors. It was very sad when the first one left. It was hard and took a long time to adjust. But no one ever thought that this individual had “abandoned the students” or that he “didn’t care about our band program.” We all knew that change is a part of life. It happens and then you move on. Believe it or not, there IS more to life than band. I learned this very less from Mr. Hamlett.

Yes, band is supposed to be fun. But it’s more than that, you learn life lessons. Mr. Hamlett taught me things through band that I use every single day. Those lessons of hard work, determination, and the most important (and from observation, the one that seems to be completely non-existent now) RESPECT.

ehsconcernedparent
|
October 01, 2009
As a concerned band parent, I am shocked at the way the band director situation has been exploited. First our children were paraded in from of Dr. Hunt to express their emotions over a situation that they have no control over. Never has a student been able to choose their teacher or football coach or any other educator for that matter why should this situation be any different. I have been a long time band parent and I am embarrassed at the way alumni and alumni parents have behaved. This situation has had hurt the morale of the current students. I am not going to behave in the same manner and bash Mr. Maineri, that is totally uncalled for, but I do feel no one has given Mr. Hamlett a chance to speak for himself. The man is not even here and he has been degraded, slandered and made to feel he has done something wrong for serving his country. What are we teaching our children when we treat folks in this way. I hope everyone will take a step back and let the school district do their job and leave my child out of it. My oldest marched for 3 band directors and loved every minute of it, regardless of who what the director. Band builds these students futures. Let's not let someone take that away who is only worried about saving their job.
ehsparent
|
October 01, 2009
First and foremost I would like to state the facts. Mr. Hamlett, long before Mr. Maineri came on the scene, worked with the Booster Club about getting our numbers up in the Band. Since we are in the AAAA division with other huge Bands. Many parents worked with Mr Hamlett looking into other Band programs and their involvement with their middle schools Band programs. We all worked with Mr. Hamlett to bring in the middle school students and started a cadet guard. Mr. Hamlett spent countless hours at the middle school along with his duties at the high school. And fyi, he didn't have 14 staff members to help him. Mr. Maineri came to Easley to help with the Marching Band. He showed interest in becoming a staff member. Mr. Hamlett personally went to the school board and fought to get Mr. Maineri on staff. First part time and then full time. Mr. Hamlett created classes to expand the program so he could justify hiring Mr. Maineri. In my opinion Mr. Hamlett should have let the school hire the TEMPORARY replacement for him. As Ms. Pym understood the position was temporary. She went on to find a permanent position somewhere else. Mr. Maineri knew going in that this was temporary. I feel the right thing to do is honor his contract. I don't ever remember as a student being able to sit in a Booster meeting and trash a teacher. That Booster meeting was so calculated. The new principal was so impressed with the turnout. Well the meeting was mandatory and names were taken. As far as the alumni go, it was cherry picked. When I can receive an email to vote on the battle of the bands but was never told about this meeting, something smells fishy to me. There was parents and students at the meeting that were pro Mr. Hamlett but wasn't it ironic that when they tried to speak, Mr. Maineri chose that moment to stop public opinion. And as far as nobody wanting Mr. Hamlett back, this is so untrue. I have heard from countless parents and students. They are all afraid to speak up because they will face retaliation from the staff and other students. As far as the Band credits, you may go to Band link.org. As far back as 1996, we have been to state numerous times. We had the Band Directors Assoc. Award 10 years running until 2008, which as a matter of fact was the same year we only received an excellent rating at state after 13 years of superior. It is in my opinion from the day that Mr. Hamlett left, that Mr. Maineri had no intention of giving up his job. How could Mr. Hamlett stay involved with the Band? Mr. Maineri would not answer his phone when Mr. Hamlett called to check on the Band. Mr. Hamlett had to call parents. Many of Mr. Maineri's young staff members openly trashed Mr. Hamlett in front of Booster members. All I ever heard was the Mr. Maineri and his wife want to open a camp. All the show from the Band is to boost his resume. As far as Mr. Hamlett's double dipping, you might want to let him know how this done, because it is news to him. I also would like to know the School Board member who listened to Mr. Maineri's talk, and then gave into his wishes without checking the legality of it. That's what started this whole mess in the first place. I am sorry that Mr. Maineri isn't getting what he wants, but I would hope that everyone of you would like to feel confident that when you have a job with a contract, it would be honored. In my opinion, when someone brings you into a position and treats you as a equal with respect, you don't turn around and stab him in the back. What is that teaching our students. From what I have seen on facebook from Mr. Maineri's alumni, I am appalled. They talk about what great leadership they had but yet the go around trashing and boarder line slandering another person. And some of these students have parents on staff at Easley High School. Shame on you. This was a personnel issue and it is now a ridiculous mess. If anything, it has divided the Band. I don't see any respect or adult behavior going on here. Mr. Hamlett is coming back. What everyone needs to do now is get over it and try to make it a smooth transition for the students. Things change, and how we handle it is part of being an adult.
ehsbandalumni
|
October 01, 2009
As far I am concerned bringing Hamlett back is the best decision. As I EHS Band Alumni I have witnessed Mainieri first hand. The fact that he has yelled at my mother in front of staff, made rude comments about me in front of other band students and others. As far as the middle school program goes Hamlett got that started. He worked very hard to get Mainieri this job and he knew good and well that Hamlett was coming back. There is only a few alumni speaking out and they are all on Mainier's behalf. I'm not. I think that since all the "Mainieri groupies" want to get personal that it's our turn. Mr. Hamlett wanted to serve our country, EXCUSE HIM! Where was Mainieri looking out for the band when a student was laying on the bleachers Friday at the football game hardly breathing? NO WHERE TO BE FOUND, they had to get the football's doctor out there to look after her while he was yelling at her to get up; that's definitely looking at the best interest of the students. If we haven't all noticed that band numbers are down this year. It's unbelievable how many people are against him coming back when they haven't ever been under Mr. Hamlett's direction. As far as the meeting about it when all these students wanted Mr. Mainieri to stay, the band was forced to be in the room they were taken off of the band field at a practice for this.. it was quite the turn out huh? An e-mail was sent out telling others it was MANDATORY. I think this has all gone way too far and gotten way too personal; it's all over facebook and myspace if you want to get personal i can get personal too. Being threatened in the band room and telling Mainieri and he said "it'll all blow over" that's really looking out. The band oughta be REAL good considering they have 13 staff members which if i might add, i thought being a employee of the school district meant not hanging out with students outside of school. And, the "just a job to Hamlett" comment.. at a exhibition my Junior year Mainieri said he wants to start a camp with his wife and that's what he really wants to do so obviously "this is just a job" to him as well. I think everyone should speak for themselves not everyone thinks that Hamlett shouldn't come back. Most of the people for hamlett have kept their mouth shut, until now. The leadership that has been taught by Mainieri obviously didn't go very far, considering they post rude and obnoxious things about Hamlett all over their facebook pages, that's really showing good leadership. I feel this should have been an easy transaction in no way was Mainieri going to loose his job but, the power went straight to his head and in no way is he ready to be knocked off his high horse yet. I think getting parents to speak out is very immature of Mainieri and sitting at the board meeting to listen to all these "wonderful" things everyone thinks of him was also very immature. I was involved in the band program all four years and I was under the direction of Mr. Hamlett and my PERSONAL opinion is, he is better suited for the job. Mr. Hamlett didn't need 212 to get the band going, because we all loved to be there and loved what we were doing. I'm sure the ones Mr. Mainieri showed favoritism want him to stay, but they shouldn't speak for the majority of the band because i know for a fact that there are people who want Hamlett back. Mr. Mainieri showed no respect when it came to money.. he is always asking for money. HELLO our economy sucks and not everyone has a "mommy and daddy" that just hand them everything. If he is better suited for this job then why is he acting like a child and like Mr. Hamlett is stealing this from him?! The plan was to get Mainieri in there and they would work together when Mr. Hamlett got back. That's down the drain considering Mr. Maineri screwed Mr. Hamlett completely over, good going. Many parents have found problems with Mr. Mainieri and have taken it further than just the principle, but to the school board. Its almost ridiculous when the reason they don't want Mr. Hamlett back is because they don't get drum major and then spread vicious rumors about the one who did and Mr. Hamlett shut him up and didn't let it go any further. Obviously people, this is all a personal issue. I'm making it personal now as well. I kept my mouth shut, but when someone isn't here to defend themselves and obviously you people have no class.. someone has got to defend them.
EHSBandMom
|
October 01, 2009
I would juat like to add for clairification to those who are not intirely up to speed: "I would like to add for those who don't know...he did leave to serve his country in the National Guard VOLUNTARILY to take a "break" form teaching... it wasn’t a situation where he was in the guard and his unit was activated …he was a teacher first and signed up for the National Guard, went to basic training and ASKED for an active duty assignment state side... he never left the country ...he wanted a break and a chance to "learn to fly?" knowing that the district had to HOLD his job...unfortunately being Director of bands was just a job to him... to the best of my knowledge because of "policy" he was allowed to double-dip so to speak and collect a salary from both the school district and the military during his two-year national guard “hiatus” from teaching. I fully support those who serve our country...both my father and husband have served our country as active duty military ...neither of them double-dipped to milk the tax payers!"
easleycitizen
|
October 01, 2009
It is an extremely high percentage of all involved, students and parents alike, who are unhappy with this lacadaisacle decision. It has been enough of a disruption to the point of Alumni speaking up, which to the best of my knowlege is unprecidented, showing only futher support for Maineri and the impact he has in lives of each and every student he has taught, past and present. After talking to many military families, a position of equal status is absolutly appropriate. If pay is uneffected, then moving from a high school to a middle school is STILL considered to be a lawfulfilling position. This is a true shame. I hope all board members involved are voted out next election if this is how they watch after my childrens best interest!!
kaypo123
|
October 01, 2009
I must implore you, to question the intent of the school board with this move. Putting Chuck Hamlett in a position of band director in ANY educational facility in Pickens County is in no way a demotion of position. While I understand the School Board must follow the laws set by the government about enlisted men and women who come back to their jobs, I bring to attention the track records of both the past band director (Hamlett) and the current director (Mainieri). While the school board must follow the rules set out by the Government, isn't their main goal to be representatives for the many voices they represent? If the school board disregards the wishes of the people, how can the people trust that form of government? I don't want to bad-mouth any party in this mess, but having been a pupil of both directors, I can understand the parents' concern. I truly believe that if a government cannot represent the people that elected it, then it serves no purpose and should be reprimanded and fixed as soon as it can be. If the school board does not appease both parties (somehow fulfilling Hamlett's wishes, while keeping the people who ELECTED those officials to office), how can these people be trusted to vote on serious issues, like budget and what books can and cannot be in a library? I'm not going to support the previous comment's last wishes, because frankly, it's the voter's choice. But i will say this: one of the wishes of a student is to have their parent actively involved in their education. If the education system becomes decrepit, the parent must act to keep the integrity of their child's education intact.

While this situation is small and miniscule in the eyes of the school board, it affects more than 200 current students, parents, and alumni, alike. Having conversations with fellow alumni, their concern is about the students. The large majority want Hamlett to be out for good, as Mainieri has revamped and changed the band program for the greater good. Personally, I agree. My first two years of high school were under the direction of Chuck Hamlett. While I was only in a second semester ensemble, we were highly neglected and that aspect of the band program was in a very decrepit state. As my last two years were under the direction of Mainieri, that ensemble was revived and began the slow process of building confident, and powerful musicians in that particular style. Not only were we good musicians, Mr. Mainieri taught us many things about life, he truly cared about us. Which is more than I can say about the previous mentioned band director. I don't want to rant and rave about how I, personally, think this situation should be handled. In fact, going away to college was one of the best choices I ever made. It makes me remember how corrupt a local government can be and then that same government not understand why the education system is suffering. Well, people, I think this answers your question. I have high respect for the school board members, they make very heavy decisions. But if a school board member completely disregards the people they represent without anything more than an, "I'm sorry." This becomes a board of personally driven, selfish men and women who can only think of personal gain. And you know what people? YOU VOTED FOR THEM! Welcome to democracy. Welcome to tyranny, as well. This is called misrepresentation. Where does misrepresentation get us? Let's look at history: Revolutionary War, Civil War. I could go on, but I want to stress the fact. As southerners we were taught to make our voice heard. So let's make our voice heard. Peacefully and like RESPONSIBLE adults. Remember your voice.
EHSBandMom
|
September 30, 2009
It is a sad day when the school board looks out for themselves and one individual instead of 140 children! It has been made clear in meetings and voiced in public opinion that the current direction is far superior to the previous. Both students and parents have stated their postion...I fear there won't be students to direct if the opinions and feelings of the students and parents aren't taken into consideration and given weight in the decisions made by the board! Just because someone holds a job doesn't mean they are good at it..doesn't mean they take pride in it...or put their heart in it....well these students do...and they want to be directed by someone who does! Shame on you school board members for not stepping up for the students and looking for an alternate solution...take the easy road...go ahead...if that's the reputation you want...if that's the message you want to send parents and students at Easley High School...mission accomplished! VOTERS REMEMBER THIS WHEN YOU VOTE...LOOK AT THE NAMES IN THIS ARTICLE AND REMEMBER THEM AT THE POLLS!
Weather
Sponsored By:

Lottery
Sponsored By:

Stocks
Sponsored By:

Gas Prices
Sponsored By:

Featured Businesses
Recipes
Sponsored By: